In Greek mythology, Sisyphus was condemned to push a massive boulder up a hill, only for it to roll back down each time he neared the top. His punishment was not really the task itself, but utterly monotonous and seemingly pointless repetition of it. No matter how much effort he put in, he would eventually find himself back where he started.
There is something uncomfortably familiar about that story when I think about disaster. It goes a little like this: we respond. We recover, hold inquiries, write reports, revise plans and promise to learn. We rebuild homes, roads and communities, and eventually life returns to something resembling normal. We do a little preparation then another hazard arrives and many of the same problems we discovered last time appear again.
We push the rock up, it rolls back down.
This isn’t because we know nothing about disaster. We understand hazards extraordinarily well and have become very good at modelling floods, predicting fire behaviour, tracking disease and identifying communities at risk. We have emergency plans, building standards, warning systems, insurance, mitigation programs and increasingly sophisticated ways of responding when things go wrong. These things matter and undoubtedly save lives, but there is a limit to what they can achieve if the conditions surrounding disaster remain largely unchanged.
We push the rock back up again.
We can improve flood warnings while continuing to build on floodplains, strengthen bushfire planning while pushing communities further into fire-prone landscapes, and improve emergency response while leaving some people with far fewer resources to prepare, evacuate or recover than others.
The rock rolls back down and when disaster arrives, we then throw enormous effort into dealing with the consequences, recover as best we can and begin pushing the boulder back up the hill.
The problem is not that these efforts are pointless. The problem is that we can become so focused on managing disaster that we fail to confront the conditions producing it. We can never seem to look past the boulder or the hill to ask why it happens in the first place.
Disaster is shaped long before the fire starts, the river rises or the disease spreads, through where and how we build, how wealth and opportunity are distributed, what governments prioritise, what businesses are rewarded for, how we treat the environment, what risks we tolerate and what each of us accepts as normal.
Preventing disaster therefore requires something much broader than emergency management. Housing, planning, inequality, infrastructure, the environment, health, economics and community are not separate from disaster simply because they sit outside the traditional boundaries of emergency management. They are part of the circumstances in which disaster either becomes more or less likely.
This makes prevention difficult because it asks more of us than improving what happens when something goes wrong. It asks us to look at what happens before disaster and consider whether some of the ordinary ways we organise our communities and our lives are contributing to the consequences we later work so hard to overcome.
We have become very good at pushing the boulder back up the hill. If we want a different result, eventually we have to be willing to change the hill.