The Loop of Disaster

In May 2020, in the aftermath of the Black Summer bushfires, I started working on bushfire recovery for the NSW Government. For the next two years, I worked across fire-affected communities as part of a Rural Recovery Support Service.

My colleagues and I listened to people’s stories, learned their needs, and helped them connect with services and support. We assisted with food, clothing and temporary shelter. We helped restore electricity and running water and supported clean-up and rebuilding. Our days were filled with site visits, community meetings and one-on-one conversations around kitchen tables and on porches. There was pain, laughter, tears and gratitude.

Recovery is long and tough work. The COVID-19 pandemic only compounded the challenge. Still, we supported more than 4,000 people, from Tenterfield near the Queensland border to Eden at the edge of Victoria. I am deeply proud of what we achieved. It remains some of the most meaningful work I’ve done as an emergency manager.

But as I worked, and helped, and believed I was living my vocation, something began to shift.

Even as I supported people through the aftermath of bushfire, I started to notice a familiarity in the struggles we were addressing. My team began using words like chronically unemployed, domestic violence, disadvantage, abuse and homelessness. A pattern emerged. People weren’t just dealing with the loss of homes or infrastructure. They were grappling with long-standing social and economic vulnerability.

That realisation unsettled me. At first it was just a flicker, a vague sense of repetition. Over time, it became harder to ignore. I began to feel trapped in a loop, a recurring disaster that no amount of hard work could break. I thought back to Dungog, where three people had died in a flood five years earlier. I could see some of the same problems playing out again, only in a different disaster.

It felt like waking up next to Bill Murray in Groundhog Day, reliving the same scenarios with the same outcomes.

By the end of my work on the Black Summer bushfires, I was exhausted, physically, emotionally and spiritually. I was burned out. After two years of recovery work, navigating bureaucracy, walking alongside communities in grief and holding space for my team, I was left hollowed. I was suffering compassion fatigue, drained by the constant weight of other people’s loss.

Underneath all of that was something harder to accept: a creeping sense that none of it was making enough difference in the long term. Despite the care, the coordination and the sheer human effort, disaster kept happening. And it would keep happening, no matter how many roofs we replaced or fences we rebuilt.

That is a confronting place to land when your entire vocation is built on helping people recover.

I still believe deeply in that work. When someone has lost their home, their livelihood or someone they love, they need help. When a community has been torn apart, putting it back together matters. The people who do that work matter.

But I began to wonder what it meant that we had become so good at doing it.

Australia has developed extraordinary capability in responding to disaster. We have emergency services, government agencies, charities, volunteers, recovery programs, grants, plans and people who will leave their own families to help complete strangers on the worst day of their lives. Then, after the immediate danger has passed, another enormous effort begins. We clean up, rebuild, recover and prepare to do it all again.

I had spent years inside that effort. I knew how much care went into it and how hard people worked. I had also seen enough to know that many of the problems we encountered after disaster had existed long before the fire front arrived or the river rose.

The fire did not make someone poor. The flood did not create an unaffordable housing market. A storm did not suddenly produce social isolation, insecure work, poor health, inadequate infrastructure or a lack of access to services. Disaster could make all of those things worse, sometimes catastrophically worse, but so much of what determined what happened to people was already there.

Once I saw that, recovery began to look different to me.

Replacing a roof is necessary. Rebuilding a fence is necessary. Restoring electricity, reopening roads, providing temporary accommodation and helping someone navigate a government support system are all necessary. But if we put everything back together without changing the conditions that made people vulnerable in the first place, we should not be surprised when we find ourselves doing the same work again.

That was the loop I could no longer ignore.

We suffer disaster. We respond. We recover. We rebuild. We spend enormous amounts of money and summon extraordinary amounts of human effort. Then another fire burns, another river rises, another community is hit, and many of the same problems are waiting for us.

After years of working in emergency management, I found myself facing a question I could no longer avoid.

What if the problem isn’t the effort, but the thinking behind it?

Perhaps preventing disaster requires us to spend a little less time asking how well we respond when things go wrong, and a little more time asking why we keep allowing the conditions for them to go so badly wrong in the first place.

Next
Next

Sisyphean Disaster